Water Injection Myths Debunked
#1
Guest
Posts: n/a
Water Injection Myths Debunked
As a frequent lurker, and closet WRX fan, I thought I would steer you guys to a thread I posted recently on the MR2 board about water injection. As many of you already know, Subaru has been using this technology on their WRC cars for some time now due to the extreme heat these motors develop.
Thanks to a client I now represent here in the U.S., ERL/Aquamist, this technology has trickled down from WRC rally to forced induction street performance.
While I have seen discussion lately of intercooler water sprayers, and rumor has it that the new STI will feature same, I thought some of you here might find the information useful as well:
Click Here
Also, feel free to contact me directly with any questions.
-- DavidV
Thanks to a client I now represent here in the U.S., ERL/Aquamist, this technology has trickled down from WRC rally to forced induction street performance.
While I have seen discussion lately of intercooler water sprayers, and rumor has it that the new STI will feature same, I thought some of you here might find the information useful as well:
Click Here
Also, feel free to contact me directly with any questions.
-- DavidV
Last edited by DavidV; 12-14-2002 at 12:55 PM.
#4
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by SuicidalLabRat
Good information, though its important people understand water injection and water sprayer are two completely different mechanisms.
SLR-
Good information, though its important people understand water injection and water sprayer are two completely different mechanisms.
SLR-
Ford also offered Aquamist water injection as an OEM factory part on its homologation version of the Ford Escort Cosworth in Europe.
-- DavidV
#7
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by Steppin Razor
So how large are the water containers that come with the kits, in gallons?
So how large are the water containers that come with the kits, in gallons?
Personally, I run a Summit Racing fuel cell as my water reservoir.
-- DavidV
#8
i'm a big proponent of w.i.......but from your link(not saying that you are),it almost seems like you're using a scare tactic to get people to use w.i.
for instance:
".....That's right. A little turn on the boost controller ****, or switching to a bigger turbo, and Toyota's ECU tuning for ignition (and to a lesser extent, fuel) becomes far too aggressive. The little stock IC struggles to keep up and, before you know it, bye-bye engine.
And this is not just happening to the crazy monster horsepower guys -- this is happening to guys making less than 300 hp at the flywheel. ..........."
i realized your a salesman and is out to push the product, and i'm sure you didn't have any intent to scare anybody into using w.i., i'm just saying from reading your post that, that's how it came across to me.....and i luv w.i.
so have you gotten any data on egt using w.i.?
for instance:
".....That's right. A little turn on the boost controller ****, or switching to a bigger turbo, and Toyota's ECU tuning for ignition (and to a lesser extent, fuel) becomes far too aggressive. The little stock IC struggles to keep up and, before you know it, bye-bye engine.
And this is not just happening to the crazy monster horsepower guys -- this is happening to guys making less than 300 hp at the flywheel. ..........."
i realized your a salesman and is out to push the product, and i'm sure you didn't have any intent to scare anybody into using w.i., i'm just saying from reading your post that, that's how it came across to me.....and i luv w.i.
so have you gotten any data on egt using w.i.?
#9
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by capt'n'caveman
i'm a big proponent of w.i.......but from your link(not saying that you are),it almost seems like you're using a scare tactic to get people to use w.i.
for instance:
".....That's right. A little turn on the boost controller ****, or switching to a bigger turbo, and Toyota's ECU tuning for ignition (and to a lesser extent, fuel) becomes far too aggressive. The little stock IC struggles to keep up and, before you know it, bye-bye engine.
And this is not just happening to the crazy monster horsepower guys -- this is happening to guys making less than 300 hp at the flywheel. ..........."
i realized your a salesman and is out to push the product, and i'm sure you didn't have any intent to scare anybody into using w.i., i'm just saying from reading your post that, that's how it came across to me.....and i luv w.i.
so have you gotten any data on egt using w.i.?
i'm a big proponent of w.i.......but from your link(not saying that you are),it almost seems like you're using a scare tactic to get people to use w.i.
for instance:
".....That's right. A little turn on the boost controller ****, or switching to a bigger turbo, and Toyota's ECU tuning for ignition (and to a lesser extent, fuel) becomes far too aggressive. The little stock IC struggles to keep up and, before you know it, bye-bye engine.
And this is not just happening to the crazy monster horsepower guys -- this is happening to guys making less than 300 hp at the flywheel. ..........."
i realized your a salesman and is out to push the product, and i'm sure you didn't have any intent to scare anybody into using w.i., i'm just saying from reading your post that, that's how it came across to me.....and i luv w.i.
so have you gotten any data on egt using w.i.?
You'll notice that in 12 pages of discussion on the MR2 board, no one has really disputed these claims. Unfortunately, those of us in the MR2 community know far too many fellow MR2 owners, as well as third Gen RX-7 owners, who have already lost motors to heat induced detonation. Call it a scare tactic, but I would hate to see boost happy WRX guys suffer the same fate.
-- DavidV
#11
Guest
Posts: n/a
I don't have any EGT data on my own car. However, I grabbed these testimonials online and I'm sure there are others as well:
Syclone
"The most significant aspect of the 40°C EGT reduction is as evidence of how water is affecting the peak combustion chamber temperatures, thus suppressing the onset of detonation. The temperature reduction is significant and permits increased boost... timing... power. Such a reduction can, for instance, mean the difference between piston crown meltdown... or not."
http://www.syclone.freeserve.co.uk/waterinjection.htm
Dinan SC M3
"I have a '99 M3 with a Dinan SC kit, which Ive boosted to 11 psi, with the only charge air cooling in use provided by your kit. Everything was very good throughout the cooler months, but I was really waiting to see what happened on those 90 degree plus days...
Today is such a day up here....I just took a few hard runs to rev limiter, and Im very pleased to say that my EGT values never exceeded 1200 degrees! As a matter of fact, I register a higher temp when driving at say 4500 rpm cruise, when no water is spraying, ie, when Im hardly making boost....When Im heavy into the boost, like over 4 psi, and the water is spraying, the temps are fine... "
http://www.activeautowerke.com/Wate...testimonial.asp
MKIV Supra TT
"However, under extreme conditions such as very high ambients of 25 deg C or more and under full power for extended periods, exhaust gas temperature can rise above the 900~950 degC threshold. The most I have seen without water injection is 1050, and whilst no problems were reported it would be unwise to continue running the vehicle at this excessive limit, even at the very short time periods involved. With water, the most I have ever seen is 900 degC."
Anyone else?
-- DavidV
Syclone
"The most significant aspect of the 40°C EGT reduction is as evidence of how water is affecting the peak combustion chamber temperatures, thus suppressing the onset of detonation. The temperature reduction is significant and permits increased boost... timing... power. Such a reduction can, for instance, mean the difference between piston crown meltdown... or not."
http://www.syclone.freeserve.co.uk/waterinjection.htm
Dinan SC M3
"I have a '99 M3 with a Dinan SC kit, which Ive boosted to 11 psi, with the only charge air cooling in use provided by your kit. Everything was very good throughout the cooler months, but I was really waiting to see what happened on those 90 degree plus days...
Today is such a day up here....I just took a few hard runs to rev limiter, and Im very pleased to say that my EGT values never exceeded 1200 degrees! As a matter of fact, I register a higher temp when driving at say 4500 rpm cruise, when no water is spraying, ie, when Im hardly making boost....When Im heavy into the boost, like over 4 psi, and the water is spraying, the temps are fine... "
http://www.activeautowerke.com/Wate...testimonial.asp
MKIV Supra TT
"However, under extreme conditions such as very high ambients of 25 deg C or more and under full power for extended periods, exhaust gas temperature can rise above the 900~950 degC threshold. The most I have seen without water injection is 1050, and whilst no problems were reported it would be unwise to continue running the vehicle at this excessive limit, even at the very short time periods involved. With water, the most I have ever seen is 900 degC."
Anyone else?
-- DavidV
Last edited by DavidV; 12-16-2002 at 10:37 PM.
#12
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 2,504
From: Leg Humper
Car Info: '03 WRX wagon, faster than walkin'
A couple of questions:
1. How much water is required for a tank of gas?
2. Can you vary the ammount of water from the injector in order to increase flow for increased HP (for example installing a larger turbo, I'd like a little more water to keep the same anti knock index).
3. How long, typically, does the pump last? Who makes these pumps?
4. Where do you install the injector, I would think in a WRX I'd like to inject water before the intercooler to keep charge temps to a minimum.
5. Who sells these kits? I am very seriously considering doing this since my car gets really poor hP due to pinging, this may help control that.
Thanks for you input.
1. How much water is required for a tank of gas?
2. Can you vary the ammount of water from the injector in order to increase flow for increased HP (for example installing a larger turbo, I'd like a little more water to keep the same anti knock index).
3. How long, typically, does the pump last? Who makes these pumps?
4. Where do you install the injector, I would think in a WRX I'd like to inject water before the intercooler to keep charge temps to a minimum.
5. Who sells these kits? I am very seriously considering doing this since my car gets really poor hP due to pinging, this may help control that.
Thanks for you input.
#14
Guest
Posts: n/a
Good questions, AntiochCali.
Depends how you have your water injections set up. Is it an Aquamist system 1S or comparable that comes on every time you hit boost? Is so, you'll go through a bit more water. If its something like a system 2C or 2S that you have mapped, you will go through quite a bit less. Other variables include how you drive the car and nozzle size.
Using a system 2S on my MR2, I top off my reservoir every 3-4 weeks for street driving. So maybe every third fill-up or so?
Yes, on the System 1S, this is done through nozzle sizing (bigger nozzle = more water, smaller = less). On the systems 2C and 2S you can remap the water delivery as needed through either a standalone ECU (2C) or handheld controller (2S).
I have yet to see one of ours fail. The pumps supplied with the Aquamist kits are the same ones used in WRC applications.
For best results, I recommend injecting it right before the throttle body. This ensures that you get the full benefit of in-cylinder cooling.
Feel free to contact me and I can either put you in touch with one of our dealers, or help you myself. Since I am local (NorCal) you can even stop by and check out the systems if you like.
(415) 509-2409
AIM: BoostedGroup
Email: info@boostedgroup.com
-- DavidV
Originally posted by AntiochCali
A couple of questions:
1. How much water is required for a tank of gas?
A couple of questions:
1. How much water is required for a tank of gas?
Using a system 2S on my MR2, I top off my reservoir every 3-4 weeks for street driving. So maybe every third fill-up or so?
2. Can you vary the ammount of water from the injector in order to increase flow for increased HP (for example installing a larger turbo, I'd like a little more water to keep the same anti knock index).
3. How long, typically, does the pump last? Who makes these pumps?).
4. Where do you install the injector, I would think in a WRX I'd like to inject water before the intercooler to keep charge temps to a minimum.
5. Who sells these kits? I am very seriously considering doing this since my car gets really poor hP due to pinging, this may help control that..
(415) 509-2409
AIM: BoostedGroup
Email: info@boostedgroup.com
-- DavidV
#15
could you post some pic of your set up in your car? that would give us a good idea....plus we like pics.....if you can, get one of the location of the tank, the nozzle, and the pump