Official: 2012 BAIC Fantasy Football League
#123
General Pimpin'
iTrader: (7)
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 23,019
From: Knee deep in beer. subabrew crew, ca.
Car Info: MY04 aspen wrx wagon.
Honestly hope someone vetoes that trade. Sounds to me like someone that's giving up and dumping players.
Welker... guaranteed top 5 in WR stats overall every year. Slow start but it will pick up ALWAYS does.
Bennett. Top 3 TE stats this year.
What's kenny getting? Harvin... solid start but not as good as either of the guys going in the trade. Fitz... WAY on the downside of the spectrum.
And on top of that... it leaves kenny with NO TIGHTEND at all. So he'll have to go to the free agents and find one.
So he looses two guys that are 1/2 level starters and ends up with an empty roster slot and 2 guys that are 3/4 level starters. That trade sucks for everyone that actually wants to win in the leagues except for you.
Welker... guaranteed top 5 in WR stats overall every year. Slow start but it will pick up ALWAYS does.
Bennett. Top 3 TE stats this year.
What's kenny getting? Harvin... solid start but not as good as either of the guys going in the trade. Fitz... WAY on the downside of the spectrum.
And on top of that... it leaves kenny with NO TIGHTEND at all. So he'll have to go to the free agents and find one.
So he looses two guys that are 1/2 level starters and ends up with an empty roster slot and 2 guys that are 3/4 level starters. That trade sucks for everyone that actually wants to win in the leagues except for you.
#125
VIP Member
iTrader: (3)
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 4,074
From: BAIC Wagon Clique
Car Info: '02 WRB WRX Wagon
Honestly hope someone vetoes that trade. Sounds to me like someone that's giving up and dumping players.
Welker... guaranteed top 5 in WR stats overall every year. Slow start but it will pick up ALWAYS does.
Bennett. Top 3 TE stats this year.
What's kenny getting? Harvin... solid start but not as good as either of the guys going in the trade. Fitz... WAY on the downside of the spectrum.
And on top of that... it leaves kenny with NO TIGHTEND at all. So he'll have to go to the free agents and find one.
So he looses two guys that are 1/2 level starters and ends up with an empty roster slot and 2 guys that are 3/4 level starters. That trade sucks for everyone that actually wants to win in the leagues except for you.
Welker... guaranteed top 5 in WR stats overall every year. Slow start but it will pick up ALWAYS does.
Bennett. Top 3 TE stats this year.
What's kenny getting? Harvin... solid start but not as good as either of the guys going in the trade. Fitz... WAY on the downside of the spectrum.
And on top of that... it leaves kenny with NO TIGHTEND at all. So he'll have to go to the free agents and find one.
So he looses two guys that are 1/2 level starters and ends up with an empty roster slot and 2 guys that are 3/4 level starters. That trade sucks for everyone that actually wants to win in the leagues except for you.
#126
General Pimpin'
iTrader: (7)
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 23,019
From: Knee deep in beer. subabrew crew, ca.
Car Info: MY04 aspen wrx wagon.
I'm not saying he's giving up... but it's a really bad trade. And you giving up charles would weaken your team which helps jboogy and plus... he could then trade say Ridley strait up for Charles and since no one stopped the first bad trade why would they stop the second...
Then he goes from having a 5th or 6th place team to a top 3 team instantly. He's basically got McCoy and a bunch of back ups at RB.
Just saying... wouldn't surprise me to see it happen. I've seen a team fold it up and help another team before. And like I said... not saying that's what's happening but it seems odd to me to be willing to go from one of the hottest TE's in football to an open TE slot and really gain nothing.
None of the players in the trade are upgrades. Harvin is doing well but that will taper off when A.P. gets back and when he gets hurt. LOL.
Then he goes from having a 5th or 6th place team to a top 3 team instantly. He's basically got McCoy and a bunch of back ups at RB.
Just saying... wouldn't surprise me to see it happen. I've seen a team fold it up and help another team before. And like I said... not saying that's what's happening but it seems odd to me to be willing to go from one of the hottest TE's in football to an open TE slot and really gain nothing.
None of the players in the trade are upgrades. Harvin is doing well but that will taper off when A.P. gets back and when he gets hurt. LOL.
#127
VIP Member
iTrader: (3)
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 4,074
From: BAIC Wagon Clique
Car Info: '02 WRB WRX Wagon
I'm not saying he's giving up... but it's a really bad trade. And you giving up charles would weaken your team which helps jboogy and plus... he could then trade say Ridley strait up for Charles and since no one stopped the first bad trade why would they stop the second...
Then he goes from having a 5th or 6th place team to a top 3 team instantly. He's basically got McCoy and a bunch of back ups at RB.
Just saying... wouldn't surprise me to see it happen. I've seen a team fold it up and help another team before. And like I said... not saying that's what's happening but it seems odd to me to be willing to go from one of the hottest TE's in football to an open TE slot and really gain nothing.
None of the players in the trade are upgrades. Harvin is doing well but that will taper off when A.P. gets back and when he gets hurt. LOL.
Then he goes from having a 5th or 6th place team to a top 3 team instantly. He's basically got McCoy and a bunch of back ups at RB.
Just saying... wouldn't surprise me to see it happen. I've seen a team fold it up and help another team before. And like I said... not saying that's what's happening but it seems odd to me to be willing to go from one of the hottest TE's in football to an open TE slot and really gain nothing.
None of the players in the trade are upgrades. Harvin is doing well but that will taper off when A.P. gets back and when he gets hurt. LOL.
#128
Originally Posted by bluwrxwgn
Yea, Minnesota isn't expected to do much. So that rules Harvin out for big games. And Kolb just never wants to throw to Fitzgerald for some reason. Yet Bennett is gonna have a major year for the Giants. After watching last night, Eli likes throwing to him. So there is major upside for jboogy and nothing but downside for Kenny.
#129
General Pimpin'
iTrader: (7)
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 23,019
From: Knee deep in beer. subabrew crew, ca.
Car Info: MY04 aspen wrx wagon.
If it wasn't for the empty TE slot I probably wouldn't have questioned the trade. But he's screwing himself and he's not really upgrading anywhere.
He's got 6 WR's right now... after this he'll have 7.
He's got 1 TE right now... the number 1 TE in the NFL right now by a large margin... after this... 0.
So he downgrades at TE. The only one out there worth a damn right now is Daniels... maybe Rosario. But either way it's a massive massive down grade.
At WR he doesn't really need much help. If he was trading for a better WR and a lower level TE for an upper level TE and a lower level WR then it might make sense.
But picking up 2 WR's is retarded at this point.
But what do I know... I just see someone giving away the best TE in the game and helping you out a butt load. All you're really doing is gambling that welker will go back to being welker and that's not to big a gamble.
He's got 6 WR's right now... after this he'll have 7.
He's got 1 TE right now... the number 1 TE in the NFL right now by a large margin... after this... 0.
So he downgrades at TE. The only one out there worth a damn right now is Daniels... maybe Rosario. But either way it's a massive massive down grade.
At WR he doesn't really need much help. If he was trading for a better WR and a lower level TE for an upper level TE and a lower level WR then it might make sense.
But picking up 2 WR's is retarded at this point.
But what do I know... I just see someone giving away the best TE in the game and helping you out a butt load. All you're really doing is gambling that welker will go back to being welker and that's not to big a gamble.
#131
Originally Posted by bluwrxwgn
Yea, welker had one year under 1000 yds receiving. Hard to think he'll have that again.
#132
General Pimpin'
iTrader: (7)
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 23,019
From: Knee deep in beer. subabrew crew, ca.
Car Info: MY04 aspen wrx wagon.
This is a crazy good trade. And like I said... the only think that caught my attention was that Kenny would be without a tight end and I knew he was trying to make a trade for an RB as well. I'm not sure what's going on there.
If I were you I'd try to figure out some way to get bennett though. Dude is killing it. LOL.
Welker... I don't think he's slowed down. I think he is probably disgruntled. I think it's a case of a team not really grooving right now. They're in love with the TE position right now. That'll change and welker will have a couple games with 10 plus catches.
Harvin... he stays healthy he could be huge but he'll get hurt. LOL!
#133
General Pimpin'
iTrader: (7)
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 23,019
From: Knee deep in beer. subabrew crew, ca.
Car Info: MY04 aspen wrx wagon.
And I don't think us users can veto a trade really. It comes down to the commish I think. So it'll probably go through no matter what... unless gagan got like 8 votes against. LOL.
#134
VIP Member
iTrader: (3)
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 4,074
From: BAIC Wagon Clique
Car Info: '02 WRB WRX Wagon
I'm all for trades. I find that I pretty much never get trades I want. I'll offer someone a trade that helps us both but they'll turn it down because they want more. It's like... dude... look at the numbers. I'm projected to be 10 more for the season and you're at 30 more for the season and some how I'm still screwing you? So I rarely trade.
This is a crazy good trade. And like I said... the only think that caught my attention was that Kenny would be without a tight end and I knew he was trying to make a trade for an RB as well. I'm not sure what's going on there.
If I were you I'd try to figure out some way to get bennett though. Dude is killing it. LOL.
Welker... I don't think he's slowed down. I think he is probably disgruntled. I think it's a case of a team not really grooving right now. They're in love with the TE position right now. That'll change and welker will have a couple games with 10 plus catches.
Harvin... he stays healthy he could be huge but he'll get hurt. LOL!
This is a crazy good trade. And like I said... the only think that caught my attention was that Kenny would be without a tight end and I knew he was trying to make a trade for an RB as well. I'm not sure what's going on there.
If I were you I'd try to figure out some way to get bennett though. Dude is killing it. LOL.
Welker... I don't think he's slowed down. I think he is probably disgruntled. I think it's a case of a team not really grooving right now. They're in love with the TE position right now. That'll change and welker will have a couple games with 10 plus catches.
Harvin... he stays healthy he could be huge but he'll get hurt. LOL!
Honestly its the Welker aspect of it that throws my flag up. If it was straight up, Fitz for Bennett, I would say that was a fair trade.
#135
I am still expecting the Patriots to get it together soon as they have far too many weapons not to be able to produce, but it is probably the blending of all of the different elements that is taking time as they are still trying to work out the kinks.